I spent the last couple of days working for short bursts in the studio. We've been having a heat wave and I don't have air conditioning so it can make painting challenging on hot days. Luckily in my neck of the woods temps don't often exceed 75 f. Of course, external conditions will impact a painting. When it's so hot that I'm drenched in sweat standing before the easel, it's difficult to concentrate on anything other than cooling off.
The materials used will also obviously impact the final product. This painting, a study of some pendant peonies in a pot in my front yard, was painted on Canson Mi-Tientes, an unsanded paper. While it can be a lovely surface to work on, it has its own set of challenges. It doesn't hold many pastel layers so you must be direct and have a roadmap for where you're going. Otherwise you must brush off pastel to "fix" something and risk losing the freshness of the piece. Indeed, I ended up brushing and reworking this painting because I just wasn't happy with several aspects of it.
I think there are a couple of ways to look at what constitutes success in a painting. The first one is the final product. Is this painting interesting and pleasing to look at? Does it keep the viewer engaged? Is it balanced, dynamic, and strong compositionally? If most of these answers are yes, it's likely a successful painting.
But there's another definition of a successful painting for me. While the final product may not fit into the above categories that define whether I offer it to my gallery or post it on my website, if a painting really teaches me something I consider it a success. Sometimes these lessons are needed many times! I have many paintings that never made it to my website or even onto social media that I still consider successes, because they've paved the road through trial and error to other successful pieces that "made the cut".
For example, this begonia painting lost its freshness due to overworking. Additionally, I cropped it to an 10" x 8", but the original idea was for a 12" x 9. This cropping compromised the strength of the composition, but it was the only way I'd show it to anyone or keep it out of the trash because I didn't like what was happening in the lower section. Even so, it will likely never see the light of day again, and will be pressed petals in the depths of my painting archives.
I consider this painting a success though, because it taught me to think carefully about the surface I choose to work on, to be confident in my composition and subject matter (perhaps even taking the time to do a small study for the larger study!), and to take care of myself. Instead of rushing through this piece because I couldn't stand the heat, perhaps I should waited for things to cool off.
Read More